3rd is Mary and her three daughters in NY on the roof. I think people spent social time on the roofs in New York City.
Mary and the three cousins, my father in the dark suit
My Grandmother Elizabeth (left) & her Sister Great Aunt Alma who died recently. Her son is the one sitting on the lap of my Great grandmother Mary in the previous above photo
Great Grandmother Mary played piano for the silent movies I am told.
Mary’s only Son Billy (right) was in Vaudeville.
Me, Mom Marthamarie, and dad Reginald Winston ALLEN ~1957
Shinault Family Genealogy 